Monday, January 08, 2007

Familar Territory and familiar result !! Abject surrender

Rain provided the odd optimist some relief but nothing could prevent the SA march and it was a sad end to another series that India lost shamelessly. Dravid has to take the blame for being naive in several areas - he neither read the wicket before the match, during the match or after the match. India should have bowled out SA for less than 150 in both innings, provided he had Bhajji (in place of the unfit Munaf) or he had bowled the otherwise umimpressive Sachin, much earlier. We all know Kumble; he can be effective only in certain pitches and with such a big patch outside the leg stump (where a bowler like Warne would have walked away with 15 wickets), he dished out some absolutely common place stuff and it is a no brainer that he can not bowl from round the wicket.
Between spells of rain and another wicket to the credit of Pak umpire (Kallis being given not out - at the worst, it would have made the match interesting), SA marched on thanks to the decision to promote Pollack (I always wonder, how such decisions made by Indians never work but again we are talking about a mindless team with NIL strategy and a sleep walking, energy less spent bunch). Prince was a thorn as usual and India lost it all in no time.

So, it was a tame end from India's point of view. The only positives were Sreesanth's bowling and Dinesh Karthik's energetic keeping and effective batting. The rest were a horrible let down and that includes Sachin. He has to gracefully retire now and move out.

In a shortwhile, India will play another series at home and there might be an odd bright spot but the maladies look deep rooted and the scars have penetrated too far for the confidence to return.

3 Comments:

Blogger Ram Seshadri said...

Another thoughtful post. I also think you should post a mention of Dravid's insipid captaincy. He often just does the textbook field placing and bowling changes. He appears to have no sense of momentum shifts in a game. Maybe we should do a South Africa and appoint someone young with a bit of daring. This is going to sound outrageous but maybe someone like Kaif or Yuvraj for the captaincy might be interesting.

1:48 PM  
Blogger Crick_Love said...

Thanks Ram. Yes. Dravid has been looking to be out of ideas many a time during the match. His handling of Tendulkar's leg spin left much to be desired. He was also not doing the right things in field placements and when the ground fielding went awry,he failed to crack the whip.

2:51 AM  
Blogger Prabu Girirajan said...

Dravid's handling of the team as a whole left a lot to be desired. But I wouldn't blame him alone. The reason why we lost was because of our batting. 169 on the 4th day is not a score. Take for e.g. the Pak team. They were in a similar situation last week, but their tail bailed them out with some powerful hitting. I haven't seen anything like that. What did our tail do.
Even though unpredictable, I feel the Pak's tail comes good at the right time. The same cannot be said about the Indian tail.
But again, why blame the tail when the top order couldn't do anything.

Sehwag was a sitting duck at the opening slot. For Sehwag, it has ended from where it all started.

Jaffar for me looks like a player for the slow low surface. To send him to SA was just stupidity. WI's traks are not the same as they used to be. Thatz the reason why he scored a double there. Once again in the last test, the first day track was a belter so he clicked. Otherwise his handling of the short ball was pathetic (Where is Aakash Chopra?)

Dravid, Tendulkar both were below par.

SCG was Ok probably regaining his lost touch. VVS was again Ok in patches.

With this top order we can't win even in the sub continent leave alone in SA.

Cheers
Prabu

12:51 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home